Supreme Court declines to hear case from Trump attorney involving …

Supreme Court declines to hear case from Trump attorney involving … – TucsonSentinel.com

by tophorse@gmail.com
in Uncategorised
on 5 November 2023

As the Supreme Court began its new term Monday, the justices declined to hear several cases, including one from former Trump attorney John Eastman over emails he was ordered to disclose to the House select committee investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot.
Eastman filed a petition for certiorari in April, arguing that a federal court in California wrongly ordered him to produce the emails while his motion for an emergency stay was still pending in the Ninth Circuit. He requested that the documents not be accessed by the House committee until the pending stay motion was ruled upon.
“Instead of honoring that request, the Select Committee accessed and downloaded the documents for its own internal review,” attorney Anthony Caso wrote in Eastman’s petition.
According to the petition, the committee then filed an unredacted pleading containing the link to a Dropbox folder with the confidential documents. Reporters following the case were able to immediately access the confidential documents, rendering Eastman’s appeal moot. Attorneys representing the committee asserted to the Ninth Circuit that their publication of the Dropbox link was “inadvertent.”
Caso claims that the appeal should not have become moot, because Eastman’s production of the email documents was not a “voluntary” act and that he was strictly complying with the lower court’s order.
The justices did not provide a reason for denying Eastman’s petition but noted that Justice Clarence Thomas “took no part in the consideration or decision” of the petition.
Thomas, who is under fire over ethical standards, faced criticism for not recusing himself from a separate Jan. 6-related case because his wife, Virginia “Ginni” Thomas, expressed support for former President Trump and his false claims of widespread election fraud.
Last year, U.S. District Judge David Carter reasoned that although the emails at issue fell within the scope of the attorney-client or work product privileges, they were subject to the “crime-fraud” exception.
The Bill Clinton appointee concluded that four of Eastman’s emails suggested that a “primary goal” of submitting a court filing was “to delay or otherwise disrupt” the Jan. 6 congressional vote to confirm Joe Biden’s electoral victory. The judge ruled that another four emails “demonstrate an effort by President Trump and his attorneys to press false claims in federal court for the purpose of delaying the January 6 vote.”
The Trump attorney, who is facing potential disbarment in California and nine criminal charges in Georgia over his and several others’ efforts to overturn the former president’s loss in the 2020 election, argued that the court’s crime-fraud holding was “clearly erroneous,” when “viewed in the context of numerous privileged communications.”
“The crime-fraud ruling of the District Court imposes a stigma not only on Petitioner, but also on his former client, the former President of the United States and current candidate for the presidency in 2024,” Caso wrote in Eastman’s petition.
Caso said he is disappointed in the high court’s decision to not correct the lower court’s “clear violation of its Munsingwear doctrine, which requires vacating lower court decisions that have become moot, through no fault of the party exercising his right to an appeal.”
He added: “But we also acknowledge that the Supreme Court is not a Court of mere error correction.”
In December, the House select committee recommended that the Justice Department investigate and potentially prosecute Eastman for impeding an official proceeding of the U.S. government, and for conspiring to defraud the United States. Eastman is believed to be one of the six unnamed co-conspirators listed in the Justice Department’s indictment of Trump for trying to subvert the 2020 election.
The committee wrote in its executive report that “the evidence shows that Eastman knew in advance of the 2020 election that Vice President Pence could not refuse to count electoral votes on January 6th.” It added that Eastman was “repeatedly” warned that his plan was “illegal and ‘completely crazy,’ and would ’cause riots in the streets,” but continued to assist Trump’s “pressure campaign.”
Those same pressure tactics on Pence to reject the official Democratic electors in multiple swing states in favor of “alternate” Trump electors, are at the center of the racketeering and other related charges Eastman faces in Georgia.
— 30 —
Daylight Saving Time ends early Sunday morning for most of the United States, but Arizona residents won’t have to switch their clocks — we don’t observe DST. Read more»
The Arizona Wildcats soccer team ended their season on a high note with a solid 2 – 1 win over the women from Tempe Normal School. Read more»
Tucson-area Republican state Sen. Justine Wadsack tweeted a photo of what she claims is her filled-out ballot this week. But the pictured ballot includes a proposition she’s not eligible to vote on, and is for a different precinct. Pima County officials confirmed that she was sent the correct ballot. Read more»
Sen. Justine Wadsack appears to have illegally tweeted a photo of a ballot that isn’t hers after sponsoring 18 bills focused on “elections integrity” and the “sanctity of the ballot.” After setting herself up like that, she’s hurling granite at glass. Read more»
The beloved Tucson tradition of the All Souls Procession returns for its 34th year with a weekend of art, music and honoring the dead. The events include the Procession of the Little Angels, the Dance of the Dead concert series and the main procession and ceremony. Read more»
Gov. Katie Hobbs on Thursday announced she was dedicating $2.3 million to improve Arizona elections, and she issued a trio of executive orders that are aimed at bolstering elections in the Grand Canyon State. Read more»
Gov. Katie Hobbs put four of her people on the Rio Nuevo Multipurpose Facilities District Board and triggers an “if it’s not broke, don’t fix it” business reaction. “Chillax,” says board Chairman Fletcher McCusker. Read more»
Although heat is now widely recognized as a safety hazard, there are no federal regulations for it in the workplace. Arizona — one of the fastest warming and growing states in the country — has resisted adopting a standard, even as construction has boomed. Read more»
Over the weekend, Little Amal—a 12-foot tall puppet made to resemble a 10-year-old Syrian refugee girl—traveled through Southern Arizona, stopping in Tucson and visiting Tumamoc Hill, the Tucson Children’s Museum, and the University of Arizona. Read more»
Members of the Tucson Coalition for Palestine pretended to be dead for nearly 80 minutes as of part of a “die-in” in front of the military contractor’s main entrance. Read more»
Unlike most news outlets, the Tucson Sentinel publishes our stories without a paywall. We believe a healthy community depends on everyone having access to quality independent journalism, whether they can afford to pay or not. As a nonprofit organization, we’re committed to providing real reporting to everyone in Southern Arizona.
But a single story can cost us thousands of dollars to report – some take months and months of dogged digging, others require paying for tall stacks of records that officials don’t want to provide. Some mean driving to remote corners of Pima County, and some see our reporters sitting through endless government meetings to make sure they get the whole story and not just a quick headline. Our award-winning newsroom has some of the best reporters, photographers & editors in the state, and we’re dedicated to getting the story right.
Our pioneering effort to rebuild local news will only work if enough people join our Watchdog Club community of paying members. Please join today for as little as $10/month.
For those who can’t afford to contribute right now, please sign up for one of our free Watchdog Update newsletters, and help the spread word about the Sentinel to your friends, family, neighbors & co-workers. Your contributions help the Sentinel sustain & grow our nonprofit newsroom & bolster our commitment to delivering the important independent news our community needs to thrive.
A smarter Tucson is a better Tucson — and the Sentinel shines a light on this town because we love it. Please join with us today.
I want to help TucsonSentinel.com offer a real news alternative!

Subscribe and stretch your donation over time: